Application of a Novel, Mega-event Environmental Impact Assessment Critique Framework: The 34th America's Cup Races Case Study

Trace Laskey

doi:10.2218/esjs.10616

Authors

Trace Laskey School of Geosciences, University of Edinburgh https://orcid.org/0009-0001-4299-4846

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.2218/esjs.10616

Keywords:

Environmental Impact Assessment, Sustainable Development, Critique Framework, Marine Development, Environmental Management

Abstract

Environmental impact assessments have a primary goal of balancing anthropogenic development with environmental protection. While critique methodologies for standard impact assessments are well-established, existing frameworks often fall short in addressing the unique challenges posed by large-scale, temporary events. Thus, this report introduces a novel framework designed for critiquing environmental impact assessments specific to mega-events on their use of science and analysis, adaptation to location and event specific impacts, attention to legacy impacts, and thoroughness of mitigation actions. The 34^th Americas Cup Environmental Impact Assessment is then used as a case study to demonstrate the framework's applicability.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Alberts, R. C. et al. ‘Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) Effectiveness in Protected Areas’ Impact Assessment and Project Appraisal 39 4 (2021)

Barker, A. and Jones, C. ‘A Critique of the Performance of EIA Within the Offshore Oil and Gas Sector’ Environmental Impact Assessment Review 43 (2013)

Caro-Gonzalez, A. L. et al. ‘From Procedural to Transformative: A Review of the Evolution of Effectiveness in EIA’ Environmental Impact Assessment Review 103 (2023)

Chang, T. et al. ‘A Quantitative Method to Analyze the Quality of EIA Information in Wind Energy Development and Avian/Bat Assessments’ Environmental Impact Assessment Review 38 (2013)

Collins, A. et al. ‘Assessing the Environmental Impacts of Mega Sporting Events: Two Options?’ Tourism Management 30 6 (2009)

El-Fadl, K. and El-Fadel, M. ‘Comparative Assessment of EIA Systems in MENA Countries: Challenges and Prospects’ Environmental Impact Assessment Review 24 6 (2004)

Emerson, K. et al. ‘Toward NEPA Performance: A Framework for Assessing EIAs’ Environmental Impact Assessment Review 97 (2022)

Fresh Info New Zealand ‘36th America’s Cup Impact Evaluation’ (2021)

Gold, J. R. and Gold, M. M. ‘Legacy, Sustainability and Olympism: Crafting Urban Outcomes at London 2012’ Staps 105 3 (2015)

Greater London Authority ‘The Environmental Sustainability of the London 2012 Olympic and Paralympic Games’ (2012)

Kahane, L. H. ‘The Impact of the 34th America’s Cup on Taxable Sales in the San Francisco Bay Area’ Managerial Finance 47 6 (2021)

Loomis, J. J. and Dziedzic, M. ‘Evaluating EIA Systems’ Effectiveness: A State of the Art’ Environmental Impact Assessment Review 68 (2018)

National Parks Service et al. ‘Environmental Assessment for the 34th America’s Cup’ (2012)

Nisbet, J. and João, E. ‘A Framework for Evaluating Enhancement Quality as Part of the EIA Process’ Environmental Impact Assessment Review 96 (2022)

Núñez, M. et al. ‘Temporary Structures as a Generator of Waste in Covered Trade Fairs’ Waste Management 29 7 (2009)

Parkes, O. et al. ‘Defining a Quantitative Framework for Evaluation and Optimisation of the Environmental Impacts of Mega-event Projects’ Journal of Environmental Management 167 (2016)

Pölönen, I. et al. ‘Great Differences in the Ways of Implementing the New EIA Directive - The Offerings of the EIALAW 2018 Conference’ Impact Assessment and Project Appraisal 37 1 (2019)

Retief, F. P. et al. ‘Unique Features of Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) in Protected Areas (PAs) - Towards Best Practice Principles’ Impact Assessment and Project Appraisal (2025)

Singh, G. G. et al. ‘Scientific Shortcomings in Environmental Impact Statements Internationally’ People and Nature 2 2 (2020)

Toniolo, S. et al. ‘Life Cycle Assessment to Support the Quantification of the Environmental Impacts of an Event’ Environmental Impact Assessment Review 63 (2017)

Veronez, F. A. and Montaño, M. ‘Comprehensive Framework for Analysis of EIA Effectiveness: Evidence From Espírito Santo State, Brazil’ Environmental Impact Assessment Review 108 (2024)